Free Tool · Compare Songs

Compare Your Songs: 5 In, 1 Winner Out

Five finished songs and one release date. Upload them together and every song gets the same three checks and a score. You see which one wins, and what it beats the others on.

Drop 2 to 5 songs anywhere on this card
No songs yet · 2 to 5 songs · 30 s to 6 min each
A real Songbrain comparison of five songs: Arcade Final Boss wins with a score of 86, followed by Vinland 80, Trust In The Process 75, Code Zero 71 and Phonk Overdrive 67
A real comparison, not a mockup: five tracks by Smoke-Oh, uploaded together on 13 November 2026.
The short answer

Which of my songs should I release first?

The one that wins when every song gets the same test. Upload 2 to 5 songs on Songbrain and each one is rated from the audio on three parts: hook strength (45% of the score), audio quality (35%) and lyrics quality (20%). You get them ranked, the winner on top, with the three bars next to each song so you can see what decided it.

It is free and needs no account. A comparison takes a few minutes, each song can be up to 6 minutes long, and the upload is deleted after 24 hours. Finished masters, rough mixes, two versions of the same song and Suno or Udio exports all work.

What it cannot tell you: which song people will love. The score is a rating against a fixed rubric, not a prediction of streams. Use it to compare your own songs with each other, and when two songs are a point apart, call it a tie and pick the one you believe in.

Why you can't pick the winner yourself

You have heard every one of your songs a couple of hundred times. A stranger gives it a few seconds. Those are two different experiences of the same file, and only one of them decides what happens after release.

Your favorite is usually the song you worked on longest, or the newest one. Nobody else hears the work, and nobody else knows which one is new. So the pick you make by feel is a pick about you, not about the songs.

A side-by-side comparison takes that out. Same test, every song, no memory of the nights it took. It will not replace your ears — it gives them something to argue with.

A real result: five songs, one ranking

RankSongScoreHook strengthAudio qualityLyrics quality
#1Arcade Final Boss867877— (rated as instrumental)
#2Vinland80697976
#3Trust In The Process75657874
#4Code Zero715578— (rated as instrumental)
#5Phonk Overdrive675673— (rated as instrumental)

Look at the audio quality column: all five sit between 73 and 79. The mix is not what separates them. The hook is — 78 at the top, 56 at the bottom. That is the kind of answer a single score never gives you: not just which song wins, but which part of the song made it win.

Watch the comparison · 3 min

Which Song Should You Release First? How to Pick Your Lead Single (5 Songs Compared)

The same five songs as in the table above: why you can't pick the winner yourself, the three checks, the ranking sorting itself, and the winner and the last place played back so you can hear the gap.

Click to load the player from YouTube (no-cookie mode). Your IP address is then sent to Google — details in our privacy policy.

  1. 0:00Which song do you release first?
  2. 0:31Step 1 — Why you can't pick it yourself
  3. 0:50Step 2 — What to compare: the hook, the sound, the lyrics
  4. 1:13Step 3 — Compare 5 songs side by side (a real example)
  5. 1:44Step 4 — Hear why the winner won
  6. 2:28Step 5 — What to do with the ranking
  7. 2:57Recap

What the comparison shows

🏆

A ranking with one winner

Every song gets a score from 0 to 100 and a place. The winner sits on top with its best moment and a one-line description of the track.

📊

Three bars per song

Hook strength, audio quality and lyrics quality, side by side for every track — so you see whether the hook, the mix or the writing decided the ranking.

🎯

The strongest moment of each song

Each song comes with the timestamps of its best moments. Open any track for its full analysis: loudness check, BPM, key and what the song is about.

🔁

Versions, not only songs

Upload V1 and V2 of the same song, or two mixes, and you see whether the new one actually scores higher or just sounds newer to you.

How to compare your songs

01
Drop 2 to 5 songs

Select or drag several files into the box at the top of this page. MP3, WAV, FLAC, AIFF, M4A, OGG, MP4 or MOV, at least 30 seconds and up to 6 minutes per song. No account.

02
Every song runs through the same analysis

Each track is analyzed on its own from the audio — the same run a single upload gets. Five songs take a few minutes in total.

03
Read the ranking

The winner on top, the others below with their scores and bars. Click "Why #2?" on any song to see what held it back.

04
Do something with the winner

With a free account you can turn one song of the comparison into 7 ready-to-post reels. The comparison itself stays free without one.

Questions about comparing songs

Can I compare my songs for free?

Yes. You can compare 2 to 5 songs at once without an account and without paying. You get the full ranking, the three part scores of every song and each song's best moments. One comparison per day is free per network; the upload is deleted after 24 hours unless you save it to a free account.

Which song should I release first?

The one that wins a like-for-like test, unless two are within a point or two of each other — then pick the one you believe in. The winner is your lead single, the runner-up your follow-up. A song that loses on hook strength but has strong audio quality is an album track, not a bad song.

How does the comparison decide which song is better?

Each song is rated from its audio against the same fixed rubric: hook strength counts 45%, audio quality 35% and lyrics quality 20%. The total is plain arithmetic, and the same file always gets the same score. It is a rating of the song, not a prediction — it uses no trend data and is not trained on streaming numbers.

Can I compare an instrumental with a song that has vocals?

You can, but read the result with care. Instrumentals have no lyrics score, so they are rated on hook strength (40%) and audio quality (60%) instead. The totals are still shown in one ranking, but the fair comparison between an instrumental and a vocal track is the hook bar and the audio bar, not the total.

Can I compare two versions or two mixes of the same song?

Yes, and it is one of the best uses. Upload V1 and V2 together and you see whether the change moved the hook, the audio quality or nothing at all. Because the same file always gets the same score, a difference between the two is a difference in the audio.

How big does the difference have to be to matter?

Scores sit close together: across 659 indie songs measured on Songbrain the middle song scores 77 and the top 10% starts at 85, so half of all songs fall within a few points of each other. A gap of five or more is a real difference. One point is a tie.

Do I get videos for all five songs?

Not in the free comparison — it is the ranking and the analysis. With a free account you can generate the 7 reels for one song of the comparison; that uses the 25 credits you get at signup. Whole albums of up to 20 tracks with videos for every track are part of Songbrain Premium.

Does it work with Suno or Udio songs?

Yes. The analysis reads the audio, not the metadata, so an AI-generated track is compared exactly like a studio recording. If you generated five takes of one idea, this is a quick way to see which take has the strongest hook.

After you know the winner

Stop guessing which one goes first

Upload 2 to 5 songs, get them ranked with the reason next to each one. Free, no account, a few minutes.

Compare My Songs — Free →